Blog

Why HIV is Still An Emergency: A Response to Dr. Sirengo’s Remarks

Posted by:  /  Tags: ,  /  Comments: 16

In response to an article published in the Daily Nation on the 10th of March 2011, by Mr. Isaiah Esipisu, entitled “AIDS to lose special status in new plan“, lead by the KELIN, members of Civil Society Organisations (CSOs), Persons Living with HIV (PLHIV), Tuberculosis (TB) patients and communities working on health and human rights issues have written a letter to the relevant government ministries condemning the remarks made by Dr. Martin Sirengo.

The letter outlines, the reasons why HIV still remains an emergency clearly giving statistical information on the same and indicating the dangers that may arise if HIV is given less priority. The letter then concludes by making the following demands from the respective government Ministries:

  1. An official response and clarification confirming that the views expressed by Dr. Martin Sirengo do not constitute the official government view on this matter.
  2. A public communication, in the form of a press statement or any other appropriate form is issued immediately by the head of NASCOP to correct this position in the eyes of the public and our development partners who fund Kenya’s health budget component.
  3. A meeting with representatives of the Civil Society organizations to discuss and share more information about this subject matter and jointly supporting and improving HIV and Health response in Kenya

A copy of the letter (.pdf 529 KB) is available at our online Resource Centre. Kindly read through it and let us have your comments.

We are half way the river in the fight against HIV in Kenya, we cannot stop swimming midstream, as we shall drown and loose all the gains we have made so far.

16 Comments

Jacque Wambui

March 17, 2011

arrow

As a woman living with HIV in Kenya, I feel this letter says it all. Kudos to KELIN
It had better not go ignored.

    KELIN Kenya

    March 17, 2011

    arrow

    Jacque, thanks for your comment. We shall follow up with the relevant government ministries to ensure we get a response. Thank you too for your organizations contribution to the letter.

wariara mugo

March 17, 2011

arrow

Hello KELIN, Allan and Partners who made this possible
I am thrilled that as a team we have taken a position and, KELIN through Allan and Others have made this viable.
Once again Allan, Thanks for taking this up and doing a fantastic job on the letter.
wariara mugo
advocacy officer
MSF OCP & OCB

    KELIN Kenya

    March 17, 2011

    arrow

    Wariara, thanks for your kind comments. Its important that we keep working as team to have a better impact as we continue to ensure the better care of people that we work with in the community.

Isaiah Esipisu

March 17, 2011

arrow

Am the author of the article. But what was published was not what I had intended to bring out. My main story was about integrating HIV services with Maternal and Child Healthcare (MCH). The original article had Kakamega Provincial General Hospital as a case study. I had gone on the ground and found out that the integration model had reduce Stigma.

When I talked to Dr Sirengo, he said that Integrating HIV with MCH was the way to go becais.

1. Because it will reduce stigma among HIV reactive mothers. (People do not want to go to a place known to everybody that it is a facility for HIV services. But at the MCH facility, it is not possible to tell why one is there.

2. We now have experts who can handle HIV. In the past days, just a handful of medical experts could handle the disease because it was a new disease. – it was not part of their training. But now we have enough technical staff.

3. We have drugs – though not enough. At least people can access life saving medication – which is better that what was happening earlier when people looked at HIV as a ‘death sentence’.

However, the editor stripped the article of all the important information and instead edited it to what was published in the papers. He deleted all the important info from Kakamega. (But remember – ‘The editor has the powers to edit, reduce, or refuse to use any article brought before him/her’).

THE IDEA WAS NOT TO STRIP HIV OF ITS SPECIAL STATUS – BUT TO CHANGE THE STRATEGY OF HANDLING THE DISEASE.

I have informed him of the communication though.

    KELIN Kenya

    March 18, 2011

    arrow

    Isaiah, thank for responding to our letter and clearing the circumstances surrounding its publication. We however emphasis on maintaining the quality of HIV services even if the same are to be integrated with other health services.

Paul Davis

March 17, 2011

arrow

Great job as always, thanks KELIN! — and what grievous harm was done to the article. Just like the CSO letter says, *integration* is a beneficial principle and *should* be pursued as long as we can maintain quality. The issue was the language used by the NASCOP official, which threatens to kill the momentum for funding HIV and overall health in the country.

Unless Dr. Sirengo was misquoted, then we’ll need to continue to push for a public retraction.

    KELIN Kenya

    March 18, 2011

    arrow

    Paul we totally agree with your comment. Thanks

Jacinta

March 18, 2011

arrow

Allan and partners,

Thanks for the good work. Keep it up!

    KELIN Kenya

    March 18, 2011

    arrow

    Jacinta, thanks for your warm remarks.

Renaldah Mjomba

March 18, 2011

arrow

Hi all,
Thanks Allan for the good job and well done to all those who contributed. I see the contents of the letter have been captured in today’s nation pg.9. There are few issues to do with editing (especially of the names of the organisations ), but it is good that our views went public- Thinking aloud: perhaps we can follow up with the journalist to write a follow up of the piece and focus on our reasons for opposing? That would be great!

Best wishes,
Kind Regards,

Renaldah Mboje Mjomba
HIV and AIDS Policy and Advocacy Adviser
Policy Group
VSO
 
P.O. BOX  49843,00100,Nairobi.
Argwings Kodhek Road,Timau Plaza, Nairobi
Phone: +254 (20)/5016000/5016108
Read latest blogs on http://blog.vsointernational.org

    KELIN Kenya

    March 18, 2011

    arrow

    Renaldah, thanks for your comment, i will follow up with the journalist to see whether he can publish the full letter so that it is clear to all, what we want.

Pascaline Kang'ethe

March 18, 2011

arrow

Thanks for all your efforts Allan and all others who contributed. Let’s take this forward. Good work!

    KELIN Kenya

    March 18, 2011

    arrow

    Thanks for your comment Pascaline. We shall definitely take this forward.

Brett

April 15, 2011

arrow

Great work, Kelin. It’s good to see the clarifications on the situation. Indeed integration might help reduce stigma but organisations like Kelin need to ensure this is not done at the cost of de-prioritising HIV. The approach should be to ensure that the focus and quality given to HIV treatment and care, is scaled up to the rest of the health service.

    KELIN Kenya

    April 18, 2011

    arrow

    Thank you for your useful comment. Indeed integration may help reduce stigma, but as you say it should not be used to an option of reducing priority on HIV. We have since received a response from the Minister in charge of mattes relating to HIV disowning the remarks made by Dr. Sirengo.

Leave a Reply

Your Name: (required)

Your Email: (will not be published) (required)

Your Website:

Your Message:

submit comment